Review of ‘Between Us’: A Japanese Drama with Uneven Ambition

Review of ‘Between Us’: A Japanese Drama with Uneven Ambition

“Between Us,” directed by Shingo Matsumura, delves into the emotional aftermath experienced by two formerly close middle-class families who have become estranged due to a tragic incident during a camping trip. This compelling narrative unfolds through the lens of a high school drama club’s production, presenting a thoughtful, albeit occasionally uneven, examination of unresolved grief. Premiering in the freshly competitive Nippon Cinema Now section of the Tokyo Film Festival, the film is anchored by strong performances from its leading ladies.

Ririka Kawashima delivers a standout performance as Makoto, a traumatized teenager grappling with the loss of her brother. The film’s narrative captures the journey of mothers and daughters as they navigate the emotional wreckage left in the wake of tragedy, seeking healing and reconciliation. While the film showcases distinct ambition, its execution feels somewhat lacking, which may restrict its commercial prospects mainly to niche venues catering to emerging filmmakers.

The story opens with a haunting prologue where ten-year-old Kasumi and her family embark on a camping adventure, initially planned to include her classmate Makoto and her family. However, illness and an unexpected work commitment prevent their participation, leading only Makoto’s younger brother Kenji to join the camping trip. Full of youthful exuberance, Kenji eagerly explores the campsite, oblivious to the cautionary warnings about venturing too far from the group.

Fast forward six years, and the dynamics within both families have dramatically shifted. Makoto lives with her mother, Emi (portrayed by Akiko Kikuchi), who is emotionally shattered after the incident, while her father (Yoichiro Saito) struggles to adapt to life outside a steady job, now working as a delivery driver. The mere mention of Kenji’s name sends Makoto into a defensive rage, while Emi’s emotional state deteriorates further when a library colleague inquires about her “little one.”

On the other hand, Kasumi (Anna Kurasawa) appears to be thriving with her family, which remains intact and has welcomed a new daughter, Chika. Yet, subtle signs of distress surface as Fumiko (Asami Usuda), Kasumi’s mother, observes the unsettling absence of smiles on her husband’s face, indicating deeper issues beneath their seemingly perfect life.

Matsumura demonstrates a nuanced understanding of portraying enduring grief without explicit exposition. However, a jarring news report broadcasted from a car radio introduces unnecessary clarity about Kenji’s disappearance, undermining the film’s subtlety and stripping away any lingering mystery. This overt clarification hints at a narrative shift toward a procedural storyline that ultimately never materializes.

The focus shifts to Makoto and Kasumi as they navigate their shared high school experience, notably as the sole participants of their struggling drama club. Concurrently, Fumiko and Emi’s encounter in the library about the family connected to the tragic event serves as a catalyst for Emi’s emotional turmoil.

While the fathers of both families remain ineffectual in confronting their emotional pain, the responsibility falls on the younger generation to face the profound sense of loss overshadowing their families. In a bid for healing, Makoto and Kasumi decide to create a play that embodies their journey towards reconciliation, holding onto the friendship that once united them and confronting the bitterness that clouds their relationship.

As the film meanders cautiously towards its climactic performance, it often vacillates between moments of promise and dissatisfaction, hinting at the potential for self-reflective experimentation or transformative insights that, regrettably, rarely manifest. The story bears resemblance to Lee Jong-un’s 2019 film “Birthday,” which similarly navigates the devastating effects of a real-life tragedy without resorting to dramatizations of the event itself.

The decision to leave pivotal questions unanswered is both courageous and commendable, though further exploration could have enriched the narrative. Likewise, the suggestion that the younger generation is more adept at forgiveness and healing than their parents might have benefitted from a touch of resistance or conflict from the older characters. Nonetheless, “Between Us” shines as a neatly crafted film, showcasing a commendable degree of dramatic ambition while providing a deserving platform for its talented female cast.


Read more about this topic:

‘Between Us’ Review: A Fitfully Ambitious Japanese Drama

Popular

Trending Now

Recommended