‘Reimagining Sense and Sensibility’: A Dark, Realistic Take on a Timeless Classic

‘Reimagining Sense and Sensibility’: A Dark, Realistic Take on a Timeless Classic

It has been more than three decades since Ang Lee’s adaptation of “Sense and Sensibility” set the standard for Jane Austen films. For many, including this critic, it remains the benchmark—lush yet precise, imbued with a wry humor that was masterfully crafted through Emma Thompson’s Oscar-winning screenplay. Lee’s rendition features an impressive ensemble cast that draws forth a cascade of emotions, particularly by the ending. Given this legacy, Georgia Oakley faced a formidable challenge in her interpretation of the cherished story of two sisters navigating love in contrasting manners. While her adaptation may come across as somewhat subdued in both emotion and visual tone, it presents a thoughtful and skillful reimagining. This film serves as a bigger-budget follow-up to her BAFTA-winning work “Blue Jean,” a poignant drama set during the Thatcher era. The delicate intimacy found in “Blue Jean” transfers well to the stifling societal constraints and vibrant countryside of 18th-century England.

Oakley’s portrayal of the era resonates with a grounded romanticism, illustrated through images of swaying cattails, dew-laden spiders, and drifting lilypads, mirroring the inner turmoil of sisters Elinor (Daisy Edgar-Jones) and Marianne (Esmé Creed-Miles) Dashwood. The younger sister, Marianne, is portrayed as bold and spirited, with a slightly shaky camera capturing her adventurous escapades through the forest as she learns of their father’s passing. Notably, Oakley avoids clichéd earthy woman themes, focusing instead on the gritty realities of navigating hills and long journeys via horse-drawn carriage—an apt reflection of the harsh social standards that challenge the Dashwood family’s existence.

The screenplay, penned by Diana Reid, follows the primary plot points of Austen’s novel with precision. It quickly establishes the stakes when their mother, Mrs. Dashwood (Caitríona Balfe), finds herself in a precarious financial situation after the estate falls to John Dashwood (Tom Brooke), her husband’s only male heir from a prior marriage. Before moving to a modest cottage in Devon, the Dashwood family endures taunts from John’s miserly wife, Fanny (brilliantly played by Stacy Martin). Elinor finds a romantic connection with Fanny’s brother Edward (George MacKay), deepening their bond through shared nature walks and art sessions. In a refreshing twist on traditional dynamics, it is Elinor who sketches Edward in a warm homage to their relationship. However, Edward’s timidity and adherence to convention lead him to distance himself from Elinor as her family transitions to their new home, with the help of the down-to-earth Mrs. Jennings (Fiona Shaw).

The more impetuous Marianne soon meets her match in the charming Willoughby (Frank Dillane), dismissing the awkward advances of Colonel Brandon (Herbert Nordrum). Their passionate affair blossoms in Devon, filled with music and stolen moments, but Willoughby hesitates to commit, ultimately departing for London, leaving Marianne to grapple with her love.

When the Dashwood sisters journey to London with Mrs. Jennings, their weathered, flowing gowns and wild, flowing hairstyles present a modern cottage-core aesthetic against the backdrop of their more polished, aristocratic peers. The contrast is palpable between Elinor’s cautious nature and Marianne’s exuberance, expressed through Holly Blakey’s enchanting choreography. In the countryside, Marianne and Willoughby engage in a lively folk dance, while Elinor and Edward share a subtly sensual waltz at a bustling London ball.

Oakley creates an exceptionally textured cinematic world characterized by intimate candlelit settings, hunted game adorning the walls, and a delightful array of dogs. At the same time, she employs close-up shots to reveal the fragility of Elinor’s composure when faced with heartbreak, while Marianne’s emotional upheaval becomes palpable as she discovers Willoughby with another woman.

The love stories unfold against Roger Goula’s poignant score, adding a layer of sincerity, although Oakley’s storytelling feels somewhat restrained. The seriousness permeating the film occasionally overshadows the wit intrinsic to Austen’s original work. While actors Edgar-Jones and MacKay portray their roles with tenderness, they do not quite revive the characters in a fresh light.

This difference could stem from the distinction between being a skilled actor and becoming a true star—a quality evident in Lee’s casting choices for “Sense and Sensibility.” Creed-Miles’s spirited portrayal of Marianne nearly captures that elusive allure, though her character often reiterates her desires for passion, making her somewhat predictable. Dillane, however, solidifies his place as a noteworthy talent as Willoughby, embodying a roguish charm that injects an unfiltered lightness into the otherwise formal milieu of the film.


Read more about this topic:

‘Sense and Sensibility’ Review: Moody, Naturalistic Spin on a Classic

Popular

Trending Now

Recommended