One of the most harrowing aspects of “Knife: The Attempted Murder of Salman Rushdie” is the stark portrayal of the author’s injuries in the aftermath of the August 12, 2022 attack. During a literary festival in New York, Rushdie was brutally stabbed multiple times, and the documentary captures the aftermath with heavy close-ups of his damaged body—his severely injured hand, the long line of stitches across his abdomen, and the grotesquely swollen eye that tells a story of violence. Much of the documentary’s impact can be attributed to Rushdie’s courage in sharing his scars; with footage taken by his wife, Rachel Eliza Griffiths, we get an intimate look at his traumatic journey in the hospital. This raw depiction enriches what is essentially a standard biographical profile crafted by acclaimed filmmaker Alex Gibney, a veteran known for his thorough investigations into power and politics.
Unlike Gibney’s forthcoming HBO documentary on Elon Musk, which features an AI-generated version of the billionaire, “Knife” presents Rushdie’s narrative without such technology. Instead, from the outset, Rushdie’s voice dominates the film, engaging viewers with a compelling narration that accompanies a vivid reenactment of the attack from his perspective. The blinding lights on stage transform his attacker, Hadi Matar, into a menacing figure, with each stab echoing as a visceral thudding sound. Matar is scarcely mentioned; in Rushdie’s recounting, he embodies the persistent threats against his life and freedoms since the controversial release of “The Satanic Verses” in 1988, which incited outrage and led to a fatwa from Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini.
As Rushdie reflects on why he did not fight back or flee during the attack, he delves into a contemplative examination of his views on death and the nature of fatalism. His recovery is poignantly portrayed through Griffiths’ heartfelt documentation, which includes moments like a call from filmmaker Wes Anderson. Meanwhile, Gibney enriches the narrative with archival news clips and past interviews, revisiting Rushdie’s complex upbringing between India and London, along with the emotional scars from his father’s alcoholism. Most of the documentary focuses on the events post-1988, when Rushdie’s acclaimed yet controversial work ignited a fierce debate surrounding freedom of expression.
Animating excerpts from “The Satanic Verses,” the film features stylized illustrations that capture the story of two Indian-Muslim men grappling with spiritual crises after surviving a plane crash. These artistic elements underscore the absurdity of the violent backlash against Rushdie’s work—a story inciting such fervor?—as well as the broader threat posed by religious extremism to civil liberties. The call for Rushdie’s assassination in 1989 ignited protests, book burnings, and tragically, violence, including the murder of his Japanese translator, Hitoshi Agarashi. For audiences of a certain era, this represents one of the defining controversies of the late 20th century.
However, the 2022 attack serves as a stark reminder that the threat to artistic expression is as real and present as Rushdie’s injuries. While this may seem evident to those following current events, the film imparts an emotionally rich narrative driven by Rushdie’s resilience and his unwavering support from Griffiths, who stands by him throughout this harrowing saga.