Novels such as Jean Hanff Korelitz’s The Plot and theatrical pieces like Ira Levin’s Deathtrap have illustrated that literary theft can lead to severe and even fatal repercussions. In his latest film, Neil LaBute (In the Company of Men, Nurse Betty) offers a fresh take on this well-trodden theme, which premiered at the Oldenburg Film Festival.
Murderous
The Bottom Line
Contrived and theatrical.
Venue: Oldenburg International Film Festival
Cast: Gia Crovatin, Thomas Sadoski, Jordan Baker
Director-screenwriter: Neil LaBute
1 hour 47 minutes
At the heart of the story is Marian (played by frequent collaborator Gia Crovatin), a director whose acclaimed horror film, titled “Murderous,” catapults her to fame. Her newfound wealth is evident in her rustic yet stylish mill-converted home and the classic red Porsche parked outside. One day, she is taken aback by the arrival of Norman (Thomas Sadoski), who has traveled from Iowa seeking a conversation.
Despite her initial discomfort, Marian lets him in. Norman, who served as her teaching assistant during their college days, emphasizes their past romantic involvement. He admires her luxurious home, noticing a lack of personal mementos but pointing out the high-value collectibles from legendary authors like Truman Capote and Shirley Jackson. It’s ironic that she does not possess anything akin to Chekhov’s iconic gun.
After some awkward small talk that reveals Norman’s unfortunate life situation—no job and no romantic partner—he gets to the crux of his visit.
With a pointed question about her celebrated film, he reveals that he had contributed to the original idea and suggests they need to negotiate compensation for his role in her success.
As is typical in LaBute’s narratives, the conversation takes a sexual turn. When Norman recalls her infidelity during their relationship, Marian interprets this as a cue to flirt.
“Are you suggesting that you want me to make amends with… a blow job?” she provocatively asks. Norman ponders the suggestion before responding, “I wouldn’t mind it.”
To divulge further on the ensuing heated encounter would spoil the twist. All that can be said is that the outcome is sudden and unexpected.
The second chapter, titled “Her,” introduces Lila (Jordan Baker), an older woman who claims to be a fan of Marian’s work and requests autographs for some DVDs, including one for her son. Again, Marian hesitantly invites this stranger into her home, leading to a protracted conversation that dives into the film industry’s frustrations. This moment arguably represents LaBute’s most authentic expression within the film.
As the plot progresses, hints about Lila’s true identity emerge, but they are presented with an unsubtle approach. While such tactics may work effectively on stage, they feel forced and artificial in this film adaptation. Despite the actors’ commendable efforts, Murderous ends up feeling like a theatrical exercise rather than a thoughtfully crafted thriller. Its narrow narrative scope makes it feel confined, and with a runtime of 107 minutes, it would have greatly benefited from a more concise editing process.