With three films now under its belt, the so-called DC Universe has failed to resonate beyond its core fanbase. The previous year’s reboot of “Superman” received mixed acclaim, while “Supergirl” this summer didn’t quite captivate audiences. The idea of a wider narrative connecting these characters lacks excitement. In contrast, the adaptation of the relatively lesser-known comic book “Clayface” stands out as a refreshing change, mainly because it operates independently of existing superhero franchises. This intriguing body-horror film, with its unique tone and style, brings a repugnant charm: the characters and conflicts thrive as they engage in a singular blend of genres that is both original and darkly entertaining.
The character of Clayface has a convoluted and varied history over the past 86 years, boasting multiple names and forms across DC Comics. Yet, no prior knowledge is necessary to appreciate “Clayface.” Directed by the talented Mike Flanagan, the film draws loosely from various origin stories while establishing its own narrative. Under the inventive direction of James Watkins, known for films like “Eden Lake” and “Speak No Evil,” it borrows elements from nostalgic horror films of the ’90s, such as “Darkman” and “Thinner.” The film’s impressive practical makeup effects evoke a sense of nostalgia, making it a delightful throwback.
The protagonist, Matt Hagen—an aspiring actor poised for fame—features a fresh face, played by Tom Rhys Harries, familiar for his roles in U.K. independent films and Guy Ritchie’s “The Gentlemen.” Harries combines an appealing ruggedness with deep desperation, making it easy to believe he would go to any lengths to reclaim the success that’s slipping from his grasp.
When we first meet Matt, he’s being chauffeured to a film set under the Californian sun, on the cusp of achieving stardom following an Oscar nomination. Grounded despite his rising fame, he spends his free moments with his struggling best friend, Corey (Joshua James). However, a reckless fling with an alluring young actress, Mia (Joana Ribeiro)—who is entangled with a dangerous Gotham mobster, Szabo (David Dencik)—sets off a chain reaction comprising violence and a swift fall from grace, amplified by the dark tides of cancel culture.
Bleeding from the industry’s harsh judgment, the now-impoverished Matt seeks to restore his shattered appearance through the help of Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie), who is experimenting with cellular replacement technologies for degenerative illnesses. Eager to be her test subject, he undergoes a remarkable transformation that initially restores his looks. However, the unpredictability of his newly altered cells brings unforeseen and horrifying consequences, as they grant him the ability to morph into various unsettling forms—leading to violent confrontations with those who’ve wronged him.
Though the premise may seem absurd, “Clayface” surprisingly surpasses expectations, delivering a solid experience without losing its tongue-in-cheek charm. The screenplay, crafted with clever wit by Hossein Amini, brings a sharper edge to the film’s crime-laden encounters, while also infusing the developing romance between doctor and patient with sparks of tension.
Ackie’s portrayal of Caitlyn adds depth and morality to what could easily be a cliché sexy-scientist role. The film also benefits from imaginative casting choices, with Max Minghella bringing a delightful quirkiness to Caitlyn’s skeptical police boyfriend and Dencik portraying a truly unsettling villain.
The grounded elements help to balance out the outrageous body-horror sequences, which are indeed the highlight of the film. Featuring striking prosthetic work, the film delivers a wealth of grotesque transformations that synergize perfectly with its Halloween release. There’s even a standout unsettling sequence involving glued eyelids, nail scissors, and a chaotic airplane ride that promises to haunt viewers long after the credits roll.
Watkins helms these scenes with a mischievous energy typical of a director relishing the creative freedoms of an R-rated film, crafting an odd but entertaining experience that appeals to both juvenile and adult sensibilities. If the DC Universe is here to stay, it could benefit significantly from more audacious films like this one—just not necessarily ones that fall into the same familiar traps. For now, “Clayface” confidently exists in its own distinctive realm.
Read more about this topic:
‘Clayface’ Review: DC Comics Horror Movie Is Good, Gross Fun