The first thing to note about “Charlie Harper” is that it doesn’t center on a character named Charlie Harper. Instead, Charlie, played by Nick Robinson, and Harper, portrayed by Emilia Jones, are depicted as a couple whose relationship ebbs and flows over a span of five years. The title suggests a shared connection, emphasizing their bond even amidst their separations. This film marks the poignant debut of directing duo Mac Eldridge and Tom Dean, exploring various romantic themes in the context of a relationship drama that creatively employs a non-linear storytelling approach. While the romance between the two engaging but flawed leads is occasionally touching, they struggle to keep the narrative compelling throughout.
After its premiere at last year’s Toronto Film Festival, “Charlie Harper” was picked up by the new distributor Row K Entertainment for North America; however, it is only now, over a year later, that it is being released in theaters. This delay aligns with the film’s theme of life’s timing, yet it doesn’t instill much urgency in the story. It feels more suited for on-demand viewing, weaving gracefully through the highs and lows of the central romance, but it lacks the emotional depth and momentum to fully engage its audience. Viewers are likely to suspect long before the conclusion that this couple may not be destined to last, evoking a touch of bittersweet sadness without truly breaking hearts.
The narrative initiates in the middle of the relationship, where Charlie approaches Harper at a dimly lit bar, only to be reminded by her that they’ve met before during their high school days. This encounter feels like a sequel to an ongoing game they’ve played in the past, and as the story revisits this moment later on, the weight of their shared history becomes clearer. Starting afresh as strangers might offer a simpler, more pleasant path.
Not long after, a flashback to several years earlier reveals Harper playfully pretending not to recognize Charlie during a college party on the night Barack Obama was elected president. This nostalgic scene unfolds further, showcasing their youth and a musical connection tied to significant moments in their lives, highlighted by Brenda Lee’s wistful ballad, “Break It to Me Gently”—a rather telling choice for a romance rooted in a poignant tune. Charlie is depicted as a charismatic but directionless young man, while Harper demonstrates ambition and a clear career path, aspiring to train as a chef in New Orleans. (Interestingly, this marks the second time this year Robinson’s character has been paired with a culinary love interest, following Netflix’s “Voicemails for Isabelle.”)
Their time together in Louisiana begins blissfully, but complications soon emerge. Harper’s ambitions begin to diverge from Charlie’s stagnant lifestyle, exacerbated by his developing alcohol issues. The film suggests that Charlie is a talented individual wasting his potential, but the script struggles to convincingly portray this notion. As the audience spends more time navigating their relationship, it becomes apparent that their compatibility is strained by both their strengths and weaknesses.
“Charlie Harper” is intricately crafted, with Eldridge and Dean’s direction displaying creativity and agility, compensating for the shortcomings in Dean’s writing. Cinematographer Sharone Meir effectively uses shifts in color and texture to mark different phases of the couple’s relationship, progressing from the passionate hues of first love to the clearer, more somber tones that accompany aging and disappointment. Editor Sam Levy’s work smartly reflects the shifting moods, creating a narrative that feels influenced by memory. However, some viewers might feel overwhelmed by the film’s stylistic ambitions, prompting them to question if they are investing more in the experience than they are deriving from it.
Read more about this topic:
‘Charlie Harper’ Review: Emilia Jones and Nick Robinson’s Slow Breakup