AHS Star Joey Pollari Talks About Jessica Lange’s Shocking Revelation Before the Finale

AHS Star Joey Pollari Talks About Jessica Lange’s Shocking Revelation Before the Finale

[This content reveals significant spoilers from the initial 12 episodes of American Horror Story Season 13, leading up to the finale on October 29.]

Receiving a call from Ryan Murphy about landing a lead role is a rare opportunity, and Joey Pollari vividly remembers that moment. His journey with the acclaimed creator began when he worked as a production assistant during the premiere of Murphy’s 2025 series Doctor Odyssey. This role opened doors to later appearances in the Monster franchise, The Beauty, and presently, the all-star season of American Horror Story.

“Ryan called and said, ‘You’re going to be the lead in the next American Horror Story,’” Pollari recalls, still amazed. He portrays Ben DeSoto, a character who begins as a boyfriend burdened by triskaidekaphobia (the fear of the number 13), only to evolve into the son of Satan (yes, that Satan). “I didn’t know at the time how deep the plot would go with his character,” he noted about the shocking developments, adding, “I am deeply grateful that Ryan saw potential in me. This experience has been life-changing, without a doubt.”

In the tense moments leading up to the season’s climax, even Ben finds himself in jeopardy alongside Cordelia (Sarah Paulson) and Queenie (Gabourey Sidibe), as they confront Ben’s satanic father (played by Fedor Steer and Paul Anthony Kelly). Pollari shares further details about how he landed his intriguing role, the experience of acting alongside AHS royalty, Jessica Lange (whose character’s history becomes a centerpiece ahead of the finale), and the possibility of more AHS roles beyond season 13.

***

You’ve appeared in several Ryan Murphy productions lately (Monster: The Ed Gein Story, The Beauty, and Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story). Did Ryan call you about American Horror Story Season 13, or did you need to audition?

Ryan called me directly. He said, “You’re going to be the lead in the next American Horror Story.” It left me in shock. It was intriguing, but I wasn’t sure how many scripts were finalized at that time. He outlined what my character would be like and who I would be collaborating with.

Looking back, it’s unbelievable how quickly things progressed.

Who was already cast at that moment?

Jessica Lange was on board. He mentioned I’d have numerous scenes with her, and I was thrilled. He gave me a clear picture of my character’s role and how it would introduce the existing AHS universe. I felt well-prepared and excited stepping onto the set, knowing I would act alongside such a remarkable talent as Jessica Lange.

People are calling you Ryan’s “muse.” Do you feel like a muse for him? Can you talk about your relationship?

During the prolonged pandemic, I worked as a PA for events, assisting with premieres and other gatherings. I vividly recall working on the red carpet for Doctor Odyssey in August 2024. The day before, I was preparing for the event, listening to The Power of Now audiobook—truly in the weeds. The following day, Ryan walked that carpet, which changed everything for me.

Just six weeks later, I received a call to audition for Monster: The Ed Gein Story, my first in-person audition in four years. From there, Ryan made it clear how my role had positively impacted him. Our relationship has evolved since then; we’ve dined together, and I have sincerely enjoyed our collaborative journey.

Being part of this creative process is incredible. I never imagined I’d progress from steaming curtains to standing in front of the camera for a leading role. I’m thankful Ryan sees something in me, and it has been transformative.

Joey Pollari as Ben with Jessica Lange as Constance Langdon in season 13.

Eric Liebowitz/FX

As the central character in this all-star season of AHS, you also bring a fresh perspective, not being a returning cast member. Have you followed the show over the years, and were you intimidated entering this world?

I was certainly in awe of working with Jessica Lange. I have seen snippets of the show, especially given its popularity on social media. Specific moments resonate deeply, like Jessica’s iconic dialogue or Emma Roberts’ memorable quotes.

While initially, I was familiar with some highlights, stepping into the role was a new experience. My character’s introduction coincided with my first encounter with Jessica, which added layers to the performance and created a genuine reaction to the unfolding storyline.

My exposure to Coven was followed by a visit to Miss Robichaux’s Academy, which felt surreal. The entire experience has been nothing short of amazing.

Did you know your character was the son of the devil when you accepted the role?

Not at all! I only knew that I would serve as a connecting point for other characters. It was shocking to learn, especially when I discovered the significance of having a “616” branded on my character’s back. The revelation unfolded gradually, especially during pivotal moments.

Your two dedicated episodes had a rom-com flair for AHS. The one with Madison Montgomery felt reminiscent of Sex and the City. How much improvisation was involved compared to the script?

From the moment I met Emma Roberts, there was an electric chemistry between us. We connected well and quickly established rapport. During our podcast episode together, this chemistry shone, which naturally translated onscreen. The direction was highly collaborative, with Adam Penn encouraging our input, leading to natural improvisation alongside the strong writing.

For instance, during a scene with us both relaxing, we exchanged a fun line highlighting our chemistry. Emma’s energy is infectious, and I found working with her to be incredibly rewarding.

Did you have a chance to work with nearly everyone?

Unfortunately, I missed Kathy Bates; she had only one scene. However, I did get to work alongside Angela Bassett.

Was there any initiation ceremony, considering the coven theme?

Not really! They were remarkably friendly. Yet, it’s amusing to enter this established cast with such a rich history. My character felt distinct, facing anxiety while immersed in a world filled with quick-witted exchanges and humor. At one point, I humorously found myself pinned against a wall with a knife at my waist courtesy of Madison. It was quite the experience!

Emma Roberts as Madison Montgomery, with Pollari in season 13.

Eric Liebowitz/FX

The end of episode 12 presented a significant twist: Jessica Lange’s characters Fiona Goode from Coven and Constance Langdon from Murder House are revealed to be sisters separated at birth, with Sister Jude from Asylum as their biological mother (while Satan is their father). How did the cast react to this reveal, and what can you share about your characters’ fates heading into the finale?

The cast was thrilled to see the lore unfold. When I read the script, the connections were exhilarating, and the implications were intriguing. As for what’s next? I can’t disclose too much, but it certainly points toward unexpected outcomes, with much more on the horizon. The finale is bound to be exhilarating.

Does your character circle back for future seasons? Gabourey Sidibe mentioned a possible return for the coven. Do you see Ben appearing in more seasons?

That’s really up to the creative team behind the scenes. While I’d be open to it, the decision lies ultimately with the writers. I cherish the experiences I’ve had so far, and that’s all I can say at this point.

Do you have any personal fears, much like Ben’s fear of 13? Did anything unsettle you while shooting AHS?

Not particularly. Despite some people’s superstitions, I don’t share those fears. It was fun to explore that paranoia through Ben, allowing me to infuse that into the scenes effectively.

***

The finale of American Horror Story Season 13 airs at 9 p.m. on Thursday on FX, with streaming available the following day on Hulu.


Read more about this topic:

AHS Star Joey Pollari on Wild Jessica Lange Reveal Headed Into Finale

Popular

Trending Now

Recommended